Thursday, January 22, 2009

FOCUS - Gwinnett County and Gifted Education



I have been asked by a couple of parents for more information on FOCUS - what it is and how it works. This blog post is my attempt to provide information to those parents and any others who might be interested. I've tried to make it as accurate as I can but it may contain errors. Please see the referenced web sites for more detailed information to help you make decisions about the program. I have no official relationship with the school system except as a parent of students in the system. All opinions are purely my own. This blog is long and dull so feel free to skip it if you aren't interested in the topic.


What is FOCUS and is it worth it?


FOCUS is the gifted education program for elementary schools in Gwinnett County, Georgia.

The Georgia Department of Education prides itself on being a leader in gifted education. According to Davidson Institute's GT-CyberSource, Georgia is one of only eight states that mandate gifted programs and provide full funding to support them. In addition, Georgia was one of the first to use the multiple criteria option for identifying gifted students. The state's Gifted Education Specialist, Linda Andrews, gives a great talk about how Georgia's program compares to programs in other states.

All that being said, the program is only as good as your local teacher. My children have had great FOCUS teachers but we know that not everyone has had the same type of experience.

-------------
How does Gwinnett County choose students for the program?

Most of the following information is paraphrased from the Georgia Department of Education policy related to gifted education. As a parent who has gone through the process both successfully and unsuccessfully, it appears that the county follows the state guidelines very closely. My experience is that Gwinnett County elementary schools use the fall ITBS and CoGAT testing scores to identify children who should be tested for the gifted program. Teachers and parents can also recommend individual children for testing.


The state defines four evaluation categories:
* mental ability
* achievement
* creativity
* motivation

There are two paths to become eligible for the program. The first is to have very high scores in both the mental ability and the achievement categories. The second is to have high scores on 3 out of 4 of the categories. The requirements are slightly different for K-2 versus grades 3-5.


You are eligible if you have qualifying scores in 3 of the 4 following categories:

Mental Ability - Score 96th percentile on a standardized test of mental ability. My school typically uses the CoGAT for this measure.

Achievement - (a) score 90th percentile in math, reading, or overall on a standardized achievement test OR (b) have produced a superior product or performance. My school typically uses ITBS scores for this measure.

Creativity - (a) score 90th percentile on a standardized test of creative thinking or (b) on a standardized creativity characteristics rating scale or (c) produced superior creative products and/or performances. My school gave the GIFT test as part of the evaluation process.

Motivation - (a) score 90th percentile on a standardized motivational characteristics rating scale or (b) have a GPA of at least 3.5 on a 4.0 scale using an average of grades from the previous two school years (for grades 3-12). My school gave the CAIMI as part of the evaluation process.

(In order to use student work to qualify in the achievement or creativity categories, it must be judged at least 90 out of 100 by at least three qualified evaluators.)

--------------
You can also qualify if you score 90th percentile in the Achievement category (a test like the ITBS) AND score either 99th percentile (for grades K-2) or 96th percentile (for grades 3-5) in the Mental category (a test like the CoGAT).

--------------
The following sections are purely my opinion and should be valued for the proverbial 2 cents they are worth...

--------------
Why would my school recommend not testing my 2nd grader?

If a child goes through the testing and does not qualify for FOCUS, they cannot be tested again for 2 years. Many teachers and other school personnel will recommend waiting for 3rd grade since there are changes in the criteria for 3rd grade and above. Whether you should test or wait is a tough decision you should make using the advice of school personnel who know your child the best.

-------------
What if my child doesn't qualify?

First, just because your child doesn't qualify for the FOCUS program, it doesn't mean that your child isn't smart or gifted - it only means that on those particular days with those specific tests, your child didn't qualify.

If you know that your child is smart or gifted or talented, look for other opportunities for him or her - there are a lot of them available. I can tell you as a Mom that it was very hard to hear that my child wasn't "good enough" for the program. You know your child. YOU are responsible for creating a customized education plan for each of your individual children. Don't let this one decision slow you down. You are not alone!


--------------------------------------------------------------------------
For more information:

Georgia Department of Education - Gifted Education

Rule 160-4-2-.38 Education Program for Gifted Students - effective March 9, 1998

Gwinnett County Public Schools - Gifted and Talented Education


18 comments:

  1. So, can you go to the teacher and have a meeting about how to get your child tested?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, you should be able to do that. You may have better luck asking your classroom teacher to set up a meeting with the appropriate gifted/focus teachers. The "Gifted and Talented Education" link above has some more info about the official GCPS process. (If your child is having CogAT and ITBS testing this fall, those test scores can be used for gifted eligibility.)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Feel free to contact me off-blog via my profile email address.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My child was tested and she did not qualify but i know she can succeed in this program. The school she attends does not give the results of the CoGat or the ITBS. What other alternatives do i have for her to be placed in a class for high achievers. She will be starting middle school next year and i know the school she will be attending put the gifted students in the same homeroom therefore they follow the same students all year.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi, I'm not a school employee so I don't know the "offical" answers. Here are some suggestions though. Did you get a copy of the report from their gifted program testing? If so, you should be able to see where she qualified and where she didn't. If she took the CogAT and/or ITBS, you should be able to get those scores. (I don't know if they are back yet for the 5th graders that took it this year.)

    It is my understanding that they are required to allow you to see her school file including any test scores if you request it so if they aren't giving you scores, you should go and specifically ask for them.

    I don't know what they do in middle school for students who are high achievers but don't qualify for PROBE. I know that some of the elementary schools have started grouping the high achievers and FOCUS kids together but don't know if the middle schools are doing that. Feel free to contact me via my email to talk specifics.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Parents, do you do anything special (test guide, books, etc) to help your child to be eligible for FOCUS program? If yes, can you share your experience?

    ReplyDelete
  7. My Granddaughter has been selected for the gifted program stating her second grade.
    When I used to substitute in south Georgia 10 years ago, the gifted students had their own class. Is this how it is in Gwinnett?

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is rather arbitrary to say "YOU are responsible as a parent for finding FOCUS type outlets for your kid"
    If that is the case then "YOU's" next question is: Why is it that if my kid happened to test poorly or the tests really aren't good identifiers (as I saw on another message board) that I should have to do that extra work when I pay the same taxes?
    We are very bad as a country in allowing subjective education to rule.
    My kid happens to be in FOCUS, but I wanted to point out that although it is best to be your child's advocate I would say overall that we don't do the best job in identifying or administering the FOCUS program. There was an interesting discussion on the CoGAT on this forum: http://giftedissues.davidsongifted.org/BB/ubbthreads.php/topics/91869/mdlugosz@davidsongifted.org

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll agree with you that there is room for improvement in the gifted program. It is my understanding that the criteria is set by the Georgia DOE and that GCPS is not allowed to change the criteria. I believe that GCPS has greatly expanded the programs across the county for students who are identified as high achievers but not as gifted. I believe the county would say that they try to educate each child - of course the implementation of that varies from school to school.

      Delete
  9. What does the mental part of the testing focus on?

    ReplyDelete
  10. GCPS uses the CogAT - I think it's given to everyone in 3rd, 5th, 8th grades. The CogAT publisher says it is designed: "To assess students’ abilities in reasoning and problem solving using verbal, quantitative, and nonverbal (spatial) symbols." http://www.riversidepublishing.com/products/cogAt/details.html

    Theoretically, it is supposed to measure more "capability" rather than what they have learned (the "achievement" component). The state says that it must be a nationally normed test of mental ability.

    I didn't see a specific list of authorized tests during a quick look but here's the link to the DOE gifted web page that has the guide with the exact wording in it. http://www.doe.k12.ga.us/Curriculum-Instruction-and-Assessment/Curriculum-and-Instruction/Pages/Gifted-Education.aspx

    ReplyDelete
  11. I know it can be hard to hear your child did not qualify. Back in the early days of FOCUS (thank goodness they have changed it) I tested two or three times and did not get in. I did go to Georgia Tech an get an Industrial Engineering degree. Just be a good, supportive parent and child will be successful.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My child scored well in achievement and creativity part but not in motivation. How/what tests are given to measure motivation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Gabrielle,

      You should be able to contact your school to see what they used to evaluate your child. Years ago, my school used the CAIMI but I don't know what they are using now.

      They can use a test, grades (for 6th grade and up), or an evaluation of a superior product/performance.

      I've attached a link to the Georgia Dept of Education guide that has more details.

      I will note that many (most?) GCPS schools group "high achievers" in with "gifted" students so it may be that there is no practical difference in being tagged as gifted. You may want to talk with the school and/or other parents to see what your specific school does. (FYI, one difference is that the school gets more money if your child is tagged gifted.)

      You should definitely look into the Duke TIP program. They provide gifted programs across the Southeast as well as access to above-grade level testing including taking the ACT or SAT in 7th grade (I highly recommended it for the experience if nothing else.)

      It's been a while since my child attended their programs but Saturday School for Scholars and Leaders at Georgia State University is also a great resource for gifted students. They offer classes for grades K-8 and the parent seminars are/were very good. In particular, the parent seminars can put you in contact with people knowledgeable about working with gifted students. (They might also be a good resource for answering questions about how Georgia evaluates gifted students. I'm not sure.)

      This may not be applicable to your child but everyone should be aware that people can be both gifted and have a learning difference/disability. It is very important not to let others "average" out the two when this is the case.

      It is awesome that you are looking out for your child - GOOD JOB!!!!


      --------------
      Link to the Georgia Department of Education Georgia Resource Manual for Gifted Education Services: https://www.gadoe.org/Curriculum-Instruction-and-Assessment/Curriculum-and-Instruction/Documents/Gifted%20Education/Georgia-Gifted-Resource-Manual.pdf

      Link to Duke TIP: https://tip.duke.edu/

      Link to Georgia State University's Saturday School for Scholars and Leaders: http://saturdayschool.education.gsu.edu/

      -----
      Note: I am just a Mom and have no relationship with the school system or organizations listed except as a parent.

      GwinnettGAMom

      Delete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete